Okin lecture slides 2012 1 susan moller okin19462004. Gender inequality and cultural differences susan moller okin stanford unrversiry theoms of rlsnce are undergang something of an identity cisis. Feb 23, 2016 unfortunately, okin argues, theorists of justice have neglected the relevance of gender injustice in the family. In the first feminist critique of modern political theory, okin shows how the failure to apply theories of justice to the family not only undermines our most cherished democratic values but has led to a major crisis over gender related issues. Pdf susan moller okin justice gender and the family 1991. The papers of susan moller okin include correspondence with colleagues and publishers, typewritten draft manuscripts, syllabi, teaching notes, and class readings.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading women in western political thought. In the first feminist critique of modern political theory, okin shows how the failure to apply theories of justice to the family not only undermines our most cherished democratic values but has led to a major crisis over genderrelated issues. Susan moller okin justice gender and the family 1991transfer ro28febfd7a0f free ebook download as pdf file. Gender and justice in plato american political science. However, the book has widely been taken to be making a much narrower claim. On a political register, okin s insistence on structural analysis of gender inequality is an important corrective to recent mainstream. Platos argument for gender equality rests on a distinctive view of human nature, and his elaboration of the consequences of pursuing gender equality reveal that a price would have to be paid for it that few are willing to accept. Based on this linchpin, the deeply entrenched social institutionalization of sex difference, which i will refer to as the gender system or simply gender, still permeates our society. Okin here offers a similar feminist critique to a host of major recent philosophers from different ideologies from conservatives through liberals as she presented in wwpt. Okin contrasts wendy kaminers a fearful freedom, which champions an equal rights approach, backing gender neutral laws and equal, not special treatment for women, with deborah rhodes justice and gender, which argues that an equal rights approach is insufficient to compensate for the past discrimination against women. Mar 21, 2016 monday, march 21, 2016 phil1010susan okin. Justice, gender, and the family susan moller okin in the first feminist critique of modern political theory, okin shows how the failure to apply theories of justice to the family not only undermines our most cherished democratic values but has led to a major crisis over gender related issues. Susan okin, justice, gender, and the family 1989 vulnerability by marriage introduction thurs nov 7 claudia card 1996 against marraige, against motherhood 7. Women in western political thought kindle edition by okin, susan moller, debra satz, debra satz.
Susan moller okin justice gender and the family 1991. Justice, gender, and the family susan moller okin download. Animated by the experiences that contemporary feminism has sought to articulate, and guided by a principled hostility to the. So, under this interpretation, patriarchal family forms might be disallowed by rawlss theory. Susan moller okin justice gender and the family 1991transfer. They are organized around a set of themes central to okin s work, namely liberal theory, gender and the family, feminist and cultural differences, and global justice. Gender and justice in the new testament cbe international. Okin testified at a deposition that she placed three calls to the dispatcher before village of cornwallonhudson police arrived at 11 taft place. Underrepresentation of women in government and judicial offices. The central thesis of susan okin s justice, gender, and the family that the ideology of the traditional family is the linchpin of contemporary gender inequality in the usremains significant more than a quarter. Traditionally, women have been associated with the spheres of the family, close relationships, domestic work and with the individual virtues believed 5 to make life in these spheres as good as it can get.
Women in western political thought by susan moller okin pdf. Underlying 3 j u s t i c e, g e n d e r, and t h e family and intertwined with all these inequalities is the unequal distribution of the unpaid labor of the. For clarification, let me first define justice and gender, as i use the terms in what follows. Okin argues that until there is a fair distribution of burdens and benefits in terms of family responsibilities, women cannot gain justice and equality in society. Cox medal for faculty excellence fostering undergraduate research in. Sep 16, 2015 susan moller okin 19462004 was a prominent feminist philosopher and the marta sutton weeks professor of ethics in society at stanford university. Raising one eyebrow and reenvisioning justice, gender, and the family article in hypatia a journal of feminist philosophy 3 may 2016 with 10 reads how we measure reads. Okins central claims in justice, gender, and the family a. A lesbian feminist critique of susan okins justice, gender. Suppose, then, that a culture endorses and facilitates the control of men over women in various ways even if informally, in the private sphere of domestic life. How can they be universal, pmclpled, founded on good reasons that all can accept, and yet take account of the many differences there are among persons and socal groups.
See okin, political liberalism, justice and gender. Gender justice anca gheaus 2 the value of what has long been deemed womens lifestyles. Many of todays inequalities between men and women reflect gender the social assignment of different roles identities, opportunities, duties to persons of different sexes particularly in the traditional family, with its characteristic division of labor. Joshua cohen, okin on justice, gender, and family philpapers. Okin argues that this is generally resolved by sort of taking the conclusion of a work you like, and then tacking on but, yeah, women should also be equal.
Susan okins radical thesis in justice, gender, and the family is that the ideal of the genderstructured family is source of persistent gender inequality in politics. Susan moller okin 19462004 was a prominent feminist philosopher and the marta sutton weeks professor of ethics in society at stanford university. Okin agrees that an equal sharing between the sexes of family responsibilities, especially child care, is. Pdf rawls, justice in the family and justice of the family. His argument should be considered by contemporary advocates of gender equality. To overcome patterns of male dominance and female submission, okin argues that a genderless family must be apart of a more. Susan moller okin this work is a feminist critique of modern political theory. Women in western political thought free pdf, djvu, doc, txt. Okin s writings explore the ways in which liberal political philosophy needs to be revised in order to realize the equal status of women. Publication date 1989 topics sex discrimination against women, womens rights, sex role. Today is international womans day, so i thought it would be a good opportunity offer a random book recommendation of susan moller okin s short masterpiece justice, gender, and the family. Much of okin s later work addresses issues of global justice, especially those concerning the condition of women. Susan okin s radical thesis in justice, gender, and the family is that the ideal of the gender structured family is source of persistent gender inequality in politics, the workplace, and actual families.
Justice, gender and the family the defense of an egalitarian parental leave has its deepest foundation in the problem identified by okin in justice, gender and the family. These expectations are known as gender roles, the way we are taught to behave in society based on our gender. Susan okin has written an important book on justice and the family. Susan moller okin, justice, gender, and the family. A lesbian feminist critique of susan okins justice. They tend to simply take the gender structure of the family. Elisabet puigdollers mas egalitarian parental leave. Susan moller okin suggests that one reasonable interpretation of rawlss pl is that it requires that the family be internally subject to the two principles of justice. Central to rawlss theory of justice is a construct, or heuristic device, that is both his.
Justice, gender, and the family fulfills this wish, leaving me feeling a little silly. Susan moller okin 19462004 justice, gender and the family family and justice how do considerations of justice. Justice, gender, and the family by susan moller okin. View notes okin lecture slides 2012 1 from dvm 2350 at university of ottawa. Justice, gender, and the family by okin, susan moller. Susan moller okin 19462004 was a leading liberal feminist political philosopher. Most cultures are suffused with practices and ideologies concerning gender. By justice i mean social justice or, more precisely, distributive justice that is to say, the ways in which goods. The first reported violence occurred on december 23, 2001. They document okin s development of her gender and political science courses and her struggles asserting herself in. Expectations based on gender are unjust, according to okin. Okin called 911 following an incident in which, according to okin, sears grabbed her neck and started to choke her. Gender inequality and cultural differences susan moller okin.
In justice, gender and the family, susan moller okin looks at the relationship between gender and justice. Pdf susan moller okin, justice, genre et famille, paris. Susan moller okin justice and gender theories of justice are centrally concerned with whether, how, and why persons should be treated differently from each other. During her career, okin got various awards, including the american political science associations victoria schuck prize for the best book on women and politics in 1989 for justice, gender and the family, and the allan v. They are organized around a set of themes central to okins work, namely liberal theory, gender and the family, feminist and cultural differences, and global justice. In justice, gender, and the family,2 susan okin criticizes different social justice theorists, john rawls in particular, for not critically. Justice, gender, and the family pdf free download epdf. For our purposes of a brief look at gender and justice, perhaps taking cases in point for each of the major divisions of the new testament, and yet identifying areas of social life where justice concerns are involved, may be the most instructive.
The last two decades have witnessed a renaissance in the develop. Susan moller okin is a professor of politics at stanford university. This volume stems from a conference on okin s work and contains chapters by some of the top feminist and political philosophers working today. She argues that our intuitive sense of justice requires that people.
Susan moller okin, justice, gender, and the family oxford. The author sets out to show how the failure to apply theories of justice to the family not only undermines democratic values but has led. Okin on justice, gender, and family 267 opportunity, and expectation faced by women generally. Okin s radical feminist critique of structural gender inequality the central thesis of susan okin s justice, gender, and the family that the ideology. Gender and justice in plato volume 91 issue 3 steven forde. Okin identifies that throughout all theories of justice, the family is defined as the basic unit of analysis, not the individuals.
Justice, children and family in the little world in which children have their existence whosoever brings them up, there is nothing so finely perceived and so finely felt as injustice. Charles dickens1 it has been twentyfive years since susan okin raised the challenge of gender against theories of justice. Women in western political thought kindle edition by okin. Justice, gender, and the family susan moller okin basic books, inc. Susan moller okin justice, gender, and the family 955. Justice, gender, and the family okin says traditional theories are based on the assumption that there is a wall of separation between private and public life and that only public life is the proper concern of political theory. They tend to simply take the gender structure of the family, and then employ gender neutral language in a hollow way to paper over this assumption. This gender system has rarely been subjected to the tests of justice. Okin contrasts wendy kaminer s a fearful freedom, which champions an equal rights approach, backing genderneutral laws and equal, not special treatment for women, with deborah rhode s justice and gender, which argues that an equal rights approach is insufficient to compensate for the past discrimination against women. Justice, gender, and the family susan moller okin in the first feminist critique of modern political theory, okin shows how the failure to apply theories of justice to the family not only undermines our most cherished democratic values but has led to a major crisis over genderrelated issues. Susan okin, justice, gender, and the family philpapers. But while this account of justice in the family represents okin smost carefully developed idea, it is in fact not all, oreven the mostfundamental part, ofwhatjustice requires. Okin, justice, gender and the family 129 1989 pointing out how the exclusion of the domestic from justice theories and the definition of the private sphere act to legitimate hierarchy and subordination in domestic relations. Youll learn how susan moller okin understands justice, and why shes interested in the role of the family.
Susan moller okin, justice, gnukr, and tlu family new york. Her books include justice, gender, and the family and is multiculturalism bad for women. The contemporary american philosopher susan okin examines the issue of gender and justice, and the role that ought to be played by gender in family structures in our conception of justice. Unfortunately, okin argues, theorists of justice have neglected the relevance of gender injustice in the family. Is it possible to visualize a society free of public significance of gender. This volume stems from a conference on okin, and contains articles by some of the top feminist and political philosophers working today. Pdf justice gender and the family download full pdf. To overcome patterns of male dominance and female submission, okin argues that a genderless family. Feminism and philosophy phil 169 fall 2019 tuesdays and. Justice, gender and the family, susan moller okin, new york, basic books, 1989.
491 1419 1220 277 580 8 715 1346 735 609 1340 1625 1416 753 707 269 748 1576 179 655 460 1386 75 104 1077 952 1401 1092 988 405