A study in temperament 1905 invites the reader to wonder, what really is paul. There have been numerous of influences, sources and parallels that have been raised by critics ever since the publications of both the pauls case by willa cather as well as in the catcher in the rye by j. What s important is that paul s secrets whatever they are are pushing him to despair. This study guide consists of approximately 44 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of paul s case. That year, it also appeared in a collection of cathers stories, the troll garden. According to many readers of pauls case, this is a short story that shows affection, passion, and most of all enthusiasm. However, most of the necessary literary elements were present. Theme paul s actions society can prevent people from reaching the american dream by not accepting their differences and alienating them. This analysis of pauls case is by sarah wyman, associate professor of english at sunynew paltz.
Analysis of pauls case by willa cather willa cathers pauls case is a story about a young 16 yearold man, paul, who is motherless and alienated. Jan 10, 2012 pauls case tells the story of a a teenage boy in the middle of a mental crisis. Like many of the stories in the troll garden, paul s case explores the dangers of art and the struggles of artists. Taken from her the troll garden collection the story is narrated in the third person by an unnamed narrator and from the beginning of the story the reader realises that cather may be exploring the theme of hostility. The story chronicles a few months in the life of paul, a student at pittsburgh high school, who would rather be at the opera than in class. Pauls case tells the story of a a teenage boy in the middle of a mental crisis.
One can imagine that life is nothing more than a game but when money is the main goal one would do just about anything to earn a victory. Indeed, the title of the story pauls case alludes to a psychological dossier, a case study of a strange boy who steals an exorbitant amount of money, runs away, and goes on to commit suicide. These industries defined the city at every level, bringing extraordinary wealth to industrialists like andrew carnegie, opportunity of advancement to the middle class, and highrisk jobs. Pauls case is notable for its complete absence of dramatized scenes. To understand how literary texts interact with their cultural contexts. It was first published in mcclure s magazine in 1905 under the title paul s case. He has grown up without his mother and he lives in a world where people do not take him seriously. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including pauls case. To learn how to analyze the symbolic meanings of texts.
The story chronicles a few months in the life of paul, a student at pittsburgh high. Whatever it is, paul s hijinks in new york give him the courage to face it. Indepth summary and analysis of every part of pauls case. Pauls case is a short story and probably not as famous as some of willa cathers other writings, but it stuck out to me because i could understand the character and his rebellious nature against the society that was trying to force him do things that would make him become something that he despised. Pauls case, by willa cather, is the story of a young man who is a misfit to his surroundings. Willa cather seems to base her stories off of daily life and events that she thought progressed in many lives. Sons and lovers is about the psychological development of a young man, paul morel. More closely aligned with the forthcoming analysis of paul is philip pages. Those around him think the opposite in that they feel he is not taking his own life seriously.
Wiila cather was a pulitzer prizewinning american author. Cather based pauls case partly on her own experiences with students while. Pauls case presents the story of a young man who struggles with deeply rooted psychological issues. As paul s fantasy vacation nears its end, we find out that. This section concludes with the implication that pauls dreams are unrealistic in part because even art relies on moneyand that theres no escaping from the difficult realities of everyday life. It is a testimony to the reality of youthful dissatisfactions and the common failure of families to understand and of schools to be helpful. A constant nuisance to his teachers, paul belittles the world around him with a sort of arrogance.
This study guide consists of approximately 44 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of pauls case. Hence kuttner points out that in pauls case, the abnormal fixation upon the mother is most obviously conditioned by the father, whose unnatural position in the family is responsible for the distortion of the normal attitude of the child towards its parents. He also addresses various aspects of pauls teaching, describes and critiques the related psychological theories and concludes with a valid evaluation. This would also include the thoughts and interpretations about pauls. Paul was a misfit and was unable to accept the drab reality of his daily life. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather 1076 words 123. A case for paul a look at societys treatment of those with psychological or emotional problems though pauls case willa cather. Cather wrote the story several years before freud became popular in america. The homosexual motif in willa cathers pauls case studies in short fiction.
Irony and symbolism in willa cathers pauls case essay. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. The pauls case community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. A summary of a clinical view of a suicidal young man in willa cathers pauls case. For a more detailed discussion of this incident, and an analysis of some of the alleged problems associated with pauls activity, see my discussion elsewhere jackson 2005, 270276. We open in pittsburgh, pennsylvania, steel capital of the world. The psychological sections are somewhat tedious for someone unversed in the field, but his evaluation and analysis make it worth wading through. The plot begins with the exposition, which is pauls failure to pay attention and rebellious acts.
They were hardworking women, most of them supporting indigent husbands or brothers, and they laughed rather bitterly at having stirred the boy to such fervid and florid inventions. In pauls case by willa cather we have the theme of hostility, respect, freedom, escape, corruption, determination and commitment. Pauls case willa cather pages 1 9 text version fliphtml5. Critical analysis pauls case was not, by any means, my favorite short movie. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of pauls case. Carrie obrys homoerotic impulses in willa cathers pauls case carries paper is guided by queer theory, which challenges the heteronormative way that readers often respond to. He had been suspended a week ago, and his father had called at the principals office and confessed his perplexity about his son. It was first published in mcclures magazine in 1905 under the title pauls case. Cather provides us with ample clues and descriptions of paul. Educator resources for pauls case educators at both the secondary and postsecondary levels are encouraged to utilize these extremely valuable materials to create an excellent, engaging unit on cathers short story pauls case, a story that resonates strongly among todays young students and provokes lively class discussions.
Critical analysis of pauls case essay example graduateway. A different interpretation of pauls smile arises from the detail where pauls drawing master claimed there was, something sort of haunted about his. Irony and symbolism in willa cather s paul s case paul s case, by willa cather, is a story that deals with a young boy who does not feel that he lives a life befitting of him. Paul s case, by willa cather, is the story of a young man who is a misfit to his surroundings. Pauls case proved to be compelling story of one boys dream life and the consequences that came with it. Paul s case his teachers felt, this afternoon, that hiswilla cather whole attitude was symbolized by his shrug and his flippantly red carnation flower, and they fell upon i him without mercy. However, the story certainly anticipates americas fascination with analysis, and cathers subtitle emphasizes her own interest in studying pauls psyche. Pauls case study guide from litcharts the creators of sparknotes. Willa cathers title pauls case 1905 invites us to ponder the question, what. These terms were not in common usage when pauls case was first published. Pauls case is set in pittsburgh in the early twentieth century, when the city was a major american center for the production of iron, steel, and glass. Irony and symbolism in willa cathers pauls case pauls case, by willa cather, is a story that deals with a young boy who does not feel that he lives a life befitting of him. Just like freuds dora became the typical example of a hysterical woman, we can take paul to be the typical example of. Heros psychology in sons and lovers english literature essay.
It was predicated on the short story entitled pauls case by willa cather. This is my thesis that i wrote for my english class, i got 100% on it. The world looks even uglier because of his high expectations. As it was now late in the afternoon, and paul was on duty that evening as usher in carnegie. It also appeared in a collection of cathers stories, the troll garden 1905. Jan 07, 2017 in pauls case by willa cather we have the theme of hostility, respect, freedom, escape, corruption, determination and commitment. The cool thing about combining the psychological case study with the detective case story is that cather gives us the details of the case and essentially implies that were supposed to be figuring out why he threw himself under a train.
Jun 04, 2008 he was intoxicated by the sheer delight of a high class life. Theme pauls actions society can prevent people from reaching the american dream by not accepting their differences and alienating them. Pauls case by willa cather is, as the subtitle states, a study in temperament. This could be the authors way of trying to show that pauls father feels the same about him. Also, it would be good to add a bit of analysis or information on pauls character and personality, which are important aspects of the story as a whole.
For many years pauls case was the only one of her stories that cather allowed to be anthologized. It is like a case which police investigate to determine why someone would kill themselves. Presently, the american psychiatric association uses the term to define a personality and outlines the diagnostic criteria for the narcissistic personality disorder in the fourth edition of the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather essay 2549 words 11 pages. Analysis of pauls case pauls case, by willa cather tells the story of a young boy who is disillusioned by his suburban lifestyle. Pauls lack of maternal care has led to his alienation. It also appeared in a collection of cather s stories, the troll garden 1905. Ebscohost serves thousands of libraries with premium essays, articles and other content including paul s case.
A constant nuisance to his teachers, paul belittles the world around him with a. Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to pauls case chief learning objectives. Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to paul. Reality alienation and homosexuality money and wealth quotes. They agreed with the faculty and with his father that pauls was a bad case. In homosexual identities in willa cather s paul s case the author argues that the reason for the suicide by train is that paul is modernity s victim.
Remote work advice from the largest allremote company. Courtney duban english 202 42714 pauls case by willa cather in the short story, pauls case by willa cather, a young male named paul, has his own life of dreams but consequences that later come with it. When that world does not live up to his expectations he is full of grief and disappointment. Get an answer for in pauls case, what exactly is wrong with paul. Analysis of pauls case willa cather 593 words 3 pages. Irony and symbolism in willa cathers pauls case essay cram. They, the teachers, and pauls father all think pauls is a bad case. Analysis of pauls case by willa cather 1076 words 5 pages. Curricular indicators satisfied by a unit devoted to pauls. He finds his education trivial, a sense of superiority towards his peers, and a general distaste for everything in his suburban. A case for paul a look at societys treatment of those. A study in temperament, cather is saying not only that this is a pretty interesting dude even if hes also pretty annoying, but also that we can use this study to understand people like paul. Paul s case is a short story and probably not as famous as some of willa cather s other writings, but it stuck out to me because i could understand the character and his rebellious nature against the society that was trying to force him do things that would make him become something that he despised. Laura clauser 9182008 lit 42 the emotional place of pauls case the main character, a challenging adolescent boy named paul, has an almost inexplicable ability at irritating every person he comes in contact with.
To relate the work to oneself and to the larger culture. Indeed, the title of the story pauls case alludes to a psychological dossier, a case study of a strange boy who steals an exorbitant amount of money, runs away, and goes on to. Dec 27, 2015 pauls case and other kinds of academic papers in our essays database at many essays. Introduction paul s case 1905 and behind the singer tower 1912 are products of cather s early phase, when she was working as a magazine editor in the eastern cities of pittsburgh and new york and finding her own voice in american literature. The lack of a diagnosis for paul has led many critics to develop their own diagnosis. It was paul s afternoon to appear before the faculty of the pittsburg high school to account for his various misdemeanors. An analysis of pauls case by willa cather 296 words. Pauls case was written in the context of a number of literary movements at the turn of the twentieth century, but naturalismwhich sought to portray everyday life realistically while also study the effect of environment on individual characterswas particularly thriving. Pauls case his teachers felt, this afternoon, that hiswilla. They agreed with the faculty and with his father that paul s was a bad case. Among the passages that support this interpretation are the following. Paul, pauls father, charley edwards, the soprano, the drawing master, the english teacher, the young clerk, the yale student. Her short story, pauls case, tells about a young man who does not feel he belongs in. Upon a close reading, it is evident that paul s case is ruled by irony and symbolism, which are apparent in the story through the words of the narrator.
Paul was not one of the many whose practice is inconsistent with their teaching. Paul is getting the onceover by a panel of angry teachers. Pauls case, by willa cather, is a short story centering on the psychological state of a. Willa cather again brings up the extreme nature of pauls wants and desires. The title of pauls case emphasizes the point that his cause is sort of a lost case. Like many of the stories in the troll garden, pauls case explores the dangers of art and the struggles of artists. Pauls case is useful in student discussions of adolescent issues and adolescent suicide. Paul s case is useful in student discussions of adolescent issues and adolescent suicide. A perfect descriptor of pauls case, the morbidity of the desire is what makes paul a potential case of psychological imbalance. Pauls case study guide from litcharts the creators of. What was perhaps slightly different in the early 1900s was the relatively newly available psychological language of the case that is used in this titles story. A study in temperament is a short story by willa cather, first published in mcclures magazine in 1905. Pauls case character analysis by ellie strang on prezi. The pauls case community note includes chapterbychapter summary and analysis, character.
830 534 825 642 780 1048 334 397 74 819 486 1429 1039 266 424 453 855 865 1420 1234 788 1272 1123 1239 1041 635 979 1340 1101 820